From Pine View Farm

Letting Lying Liars Lie 0

Dick Polman discusses the inability of the press to call out lies, trying to figure out why they won’t state the obvious.

A nugget (emphasis added):

You’re probably familiar with this (Romney–ed.) ad, which was aimed at the New Hampshire electorate. The marquee moment was a sound bite from Barack Obama – “If we keep talking about the economy, we’re going to lose” – which suggested that he’s seeking to distance himself from the recession on the eve of the ’12 festivities. But he wasn’t talking about his re-election campaign at all. The clip was actually from 2008 – and Obama was quoting a John McCain aide who had contended in an interview that McCain should distance himself from the George W. Bush recession.

In other words, Romney’s key clip was demonstrably false. But that’s not how it was generally reported.

A CNN tweet: “Democrats say new Romney ad distorts Obama’s words.” There it is, the doctrine of false equivalence/balance. Romney makes a charge, “Democrats say” something in rebuttal, and all charges are equal. This is what Wicker used to complain about. He said that, all too often, the press takes refuge in “statements delivered by official spokesmen,” without weighing the facts to determine whether one side is more credible than the other.

When I was a young ‘un, being “objective” meant trying to separate true from false.

Share

Comments are closed.