From Pine View Farm

Asking the Wrong Question Always Gets a Wrong Answer 2

The Complete Idiots Guide to Understanding the Middle East:  A confusing diagram.

Judging from the headlines at the news sites I frequent, the Very Serious People seem to have decided that the crucial question regarding Syria is whether or not Syria used gas warfare. Framing the question in that way implies that, if the answer is yes, some sort of attack is ipso facto justified.

Ignoring that there is no such thing as a “surgical strike” except in the fantasies of warmongers, the actual question is lost in the frame:

What would an attack accomplish, other than killing some folks?

  • Would it end the civil war in Syria?
  • Would it topple the bad guys and elevate the good guys (ignoring, again, that there don’t seem to be any good guys on either side of the fighting, just innocents in the middle)?
  • Would it protect the innocents?
  • Is there anything outsiders can do to end the carnage?

No one argues that any of these can be answered with a “yes.”

The argument instead seems to be that, by raining remote-controlled death, our disapproval would be made manifest, as a God rains lightning from the sky.

In other words, it is the “diplomatic” equivalent of punching a hole in a wall out of frustration.

The frustration still exists, and now your hand is injured and you have to repair a hole.

This is not diplomacy.

This is the impotent masturbating with missiles.

Image via BartCop.

Share

2 comments

  1. George Smith

    September 1, 2013 at 4:39 pm

    Plus you get all our six figure explainers who never took extended chemistry courses in their life explaining the “science” of chemical weapons and how “heinous” they are. The US must strike because established “norms” in warfare have been violated. Plus they’re so hooked on US technical and numerical supremacy in weapons they really do like the sword of God analogies, at least mentally. Obama surprised me on Friday be maneuvering a way out if people are willing to work for it. The British revolt gave him the germ of the idea.

     
  2. Frank

    September 1, 2013 at 10:53 pm

    I said it a long while ago, during the 2008 campaign.  

     

    Obama is a smart and wily Chicago pol.  Underestimate him as a politician at your peril.