From Pine View Farm

A Nation of Immigrants 2

Alfred Doblin is disheartened by Republican rants about brown people.

Most frightening about the tenor of the immigration debate on the Republican side is the unrelenting dehumanizing of immigrants into something less than a whole person. Maybe it is not so accidental that Trump wants to get rid of the 14th Amendment. If America returns to a pre-Civil War mentality, it can just replace blacks as being 3/5ths of a person with all undocumented immigrants.

Scary stuff. Maybe America is not 1933 Munich, but we are not a shining city on a hill, either. This rhetoric by smart, pragmatic politicians like Christie and Bush is dangerous. It shows how much both men will sacrifice to become president. They are willing to abandon all that was good about their public lives just to compete with a billionaire P.T. Barnum with straw-colored hair. Is this the only choice: The scarecrow or the straw man?

Follow the link for the rest.

Share

2 comments

  1. George Smith

    September 5, 2015 at 10:29 am

    Hoping WhiteManistan will suddenly come to its senses and divest itself of the hate, scapegoating and authoritarianism isn’t realistic. Empires decline and collapse. Nope, this sure isn’t “Munich in 1933” but we have a failed social democracy whose people share some of the very same weaknesses. WhiteManistan doesn’t have to field a majority to wreck everything, it just needs its crowd to vote as a block and for enough of everyone else to be fragmented, weak, apathetic or demoralized.

    One goal has very obviously been achieved. WhiteManistan doesn’t see any of its adversaries as human beings. It’s hard to ignore although some are still trying their damndest to insist both sides are guilty.

    I’m betting all dictatorships and authoritarian nightmares are filled with opportunistic people willing to abandon all principles and decency as needed to take advantage of any situation, just like here.

     
  2. Frank

    September 5, 2015 at 4:20 pm

    You’re preaching to the choir, my friend.

    The history of America’s immigration laws is writ in racist exclusion.